WARNING: This product contains nicotine. Nicotine is an addictive chemical.

Home >> News >> Regulations >> Vietnam’s E-Cigarette Conundrum: A Regulatory Roller Coaster Ride

Vietnam’s E-Cigarette Conundrum: A Regulatory Roller Coaster Ride


Welcome to the wild world of Vietnamese e-cigarette regulations—or rather, the lack thereof. On May 6, 2024, Vietnam’s Ministry of Industry and Trade turned the heat up on e-cigarettes and heated tobacco products with a riveting submission to the National Assembly’s Social Committee. Buckle up as we dive into this smoky saga of regulation, recommendation, and, yes, a touch of bureaucratic humor.

A Vape-less Void: The Current State of Affairs

Indeed, the Ministry of Industry and Trade’s recent declaration sends a clear signal to all stakeholders in the tobacco industry—without a robust framework, the introduction of e-cigarettes into the Vietnamese market is as unadvisable as sailing a ship without a compass. This cautious stance highlights a critical gap in national regulations, which is akin to a chef trying to cook a gourmet meal without ingredients. The absence of clear guidelines and established rules for these products not only stifles potential market growth but also leaves consumers in a haze of uncertainty, unsure of the safety and legality of these modern alternatives to traditional tobacco.

Furthermore, this regulatory void does not just impact the marketplace; it affects public health dynamics and enforcement capabilities. Without formal regulations, law enforcement is handcuffed, unable to apply more than superficial penalties to those who smuggle or sell these products illegally. It’s much like trying to enforce a speed limit on a road without signs: how do you maintain order when the rules of the road are undefined? This situation creates a fertile ground for black market activities to flourish, putting consumers at risk and undermining public health efforts. Thus, the need for a structured policy approach is not just beneficial but essential for the well-being of both the industry and the public.


Smuggling Shenanigans and Puny Penalties

This analogy perfectly illustrates the ineffectiveness of Vietnam’s current strategies in controlling the underground circulation of e-cigarettes and heated tobacco products. The existing laws are so porous that enforcing them feels like a comedic attempt to clean up a spill with a net. The fines, while nominally significant, fail to create a deterrent effect. Imagine a scenario where the penalty for speeding was merely being asked politely to slow down—it’s unlikely to inspire adherence to traffic laws, right? In the same vein, when the consequences don’t match the severity of the crime, compliance becomes a matter of choice rather than obligation.

Moreover, the lack of criminal penalties in this context reduces the whole enforcement mechanism to a toothless tiger. It’s akin to a security guard armed only with a flashlight facing off against seasoned burglars. The fines imposed are only a slap on the wrist, and in the grand scheme of things, they might simply be viewed as an operational cost by those engaging in illicit trade. Without the fear of serious repercussions, such as criminal charges that could lead to significant fines or imprisonment, the battle against smuggling and illegal sales of these modern smoking devices is hardly more than a ceremonial gesture. It’s clear that for real change, Vietnam needs to bolster its legal framework, transforming these flimsy administrative scoldings into a robust arsenal of enforcement tools.

Policy Proposals: A Light at the End of the Tunnel?

Indeed, the Ministry of Industry and Trade’s proactive stance indicates they’re far from passive in this regulatory rodeo. By aiming to revise Decree No. 67 of 2013, they are not merely tweaking a few lines of text but overhauling the entire legal framework to accommodate these contemporary tobacco products. This move is much like convincing your grandmother to upgrade her ancient Windows 95 system to something this century has to offer—essential for functionality but fraught with the potential for those infamous “but it used to work!” moments. The transition is critical, yes, but it’s not without its quirks and challenges, especially when integrating new technologies or, in this case, products, into old systems.

Furthermore, by including e-cigarettes and heated tobacco products in the updated decree, the Ministry is attempting to lasso a wildly bucking bronco. These products have galloped ahead in terms of popularity and consumer demand, often outpacing the sluggish strides of legislation. The integration of such products under formal regulatory scrutiny is akin to performing a software update on a device that’s been running on autopilot: necessary to ensure safety and efficiency but likely to bring a few surprises and system crashes along the way. The hope, of course, is that once the dust settles, there will be a stable, secure, and modern framework in place that protects consumers and keeps the industry in check.

A Double-Edged Sword: Health Concerns and Policy Pilots

While the Ministry of Industry and Trade is eager to regulate, they’re also fully aware of the unknowns lurking behind these new-generation tobacco products. The health implications of e-cigarettes and heated tobacco are still as elusive as a shadow in the night, raising concerns that are shrouded in scientific uncertainty. Recognizing the potential risks, the Ministry has wisely called on the Ministry of Health to join them in the regulatory arena. This collaboration aims to uncover the actual impact of these products on consumers’ well-being, potentially revealing any hidden pitfalls before they take a toll on public health.

To navigate this murky terrain, the Ministry is advocating for a two-year pilot program under the Tobacco Harm Prevention Act. By testing these waters, they hope to better understand the ripple effects of heated and e-cigarettes on Vietnamese society. The goal is to light a clear path forward through research and data, giving policymakers a robust foundation for crafting future regulations. The Ministry aims to prevent any widespread health crises before they ignite, ensuring that the regulatory framework is well-informed and grounded in science before these products gain a stronger foothold in the market.


On May 6, 2024, the Ministry of Industry and Trade of Vietnam presented a comprehensive report to the National Assembly’s Social Committee, addressing the pressing need for regulatory frameworks for e-cigarettes and heated tobacco products. Acknowledging the current legal void and the absence of specific import and sales policies by the Vietnam Tobacco Corporation, the Ministry recommended halting the circulation of these products until proper regulations are in place. They highlighted the challenges posed by smuggling and the inadequacy of existing penalties, which are currently only administrative and not criminal. To manage these modern tobacco products effectively, the Ministry proposed amendments to Decree No. 67 of 2013 and suggested a collaborative effort with the Ministry of Health. This would include a two-year pilot study under the Tobacco Harm Prevention Act to evaluate the health impacts and set a solid foundation for future policies, thus ensuring that any integration into the market is both safe and regulated.


KEYSTONE Products contain nicotine and are unsuitable for minors.
Please confirm your age to proceed.